Archive for July 2019

LOOK OUT CIRCULAR

For most Indians, the term LOC would normally mean the Line of Control. However in Indian legal context LOC means Lookout Circular.

Meaning of LOC:
•It is a circular used by authorities to check whether a travelling person is wanted by the police. LOC is a coercive measure to make a person surrender to investigating agency or courts of law. It is generally issued against absconding criminals/ accused to stop them from entering or crossing borders or to track /detain the wanted person and hand them over to appropriate authority.

Types of LOC:
•Local LOC: It is limited to a particular town / city area. In this case, usually the LOC is issued to the local Airport, Sea port, Train or Bus stations.

•National LOC: Is a nationwide circular to all the Airports, Seaports, and border agencies across the border within a country.

•International LOC: International circular to different countries’ Airports, Seaports and across the international Border agencies. This has a limitation of bilateral understanding between the countries.

•Section 498A IPC and LOC: Usually issued by the Police against the accused NRI husband and his family members after the Police register an FIR. In some cases, the Court orders the same against the accused NRI’s, if the accused does not surrender to the court within the stipulated time interval given.

Authority to issue LOC:
•LOC can be issued only with the approval of an officer not below the rank of Deputy Secretary to the Government of India/ Joint Secretary in the State Government /Superintendent of Police concerned at the district level. It can also be issued by the court before which the criminal case lies.

Principles to issue LOC:
The basic guidelines regarding the issuance of LOC’s in relation to Indian citizens issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs are as follows:

•The request to issue/opening of LOC must be issued with the approval of an officer in authority. The authorities includes the Ministry of Home Affair, Ministry of External Affairs, the Customs and Income Tax Department, Directorate of Revenue intelligence, Central Bureau of Investigation, Court, Interpol, Regional passport Officers, Police authorities in various States, etc.

•Lookout circulars/notice for all immigration check posts against any Indian person can be issued only in the format prepared by the Home Ministry.

•The notice issuing agency must give full identification details of the accused person on an already prescribed format. LOC will not be issued for less than three identity parameters other than name of the accused.

Performa of LOC:
•The request for opening of LOC is required to be made to all immigration Check-posts in the country in the Official Format prescribed by the MHA.
•The details of the person looked out for in the circular includes: Name, address, Picture / photo or description of the person’s physical appearance, Passport number/details, other unique identification card number, alleged offence details / case involved in.
•In cases linked to, terrorist, anti national elements etc, LOC can be issued without complying with all rules, parameters or prescribed Performa.

Validity of LOC:
•LOC is valid for a period of one year. However, in case the originating agency wants to extend the validity beyond one year, it can ask for the extension before the expiry of the one-year period. If no request is made for the extension of the LOC within the stipulated period of one year, the Immigration Officer concerned is authorized to suspend the LOC.
•In the case of Court and Interpol, LOC does not expire within one year.

Consequences of LOC:
•Issuance of LOC can impact different persons differently. It curtails person’s ability to travel in and outside of country. The person has to face arrest or detention at the place where found.

Right to Information:
LOC is highly confidential document. Unless the case is high profile, whether the LOC is issued or not is not known to public at large.

Still one can try to get the information from the following sources:

•Police Station where the FIR is lodged
•District SP/DSP Office or similar rank officer in any investing agency.
•Immigration Authorities
•Foreigner Regional Registration Office (FRRO) in case of NRI.
•Trial Court records, if court have initiated the issuance of LOC.

Steps to be followed when LOC is issued:
•Have all the legal documents with you.
•Obtain Anticipatory bail in the case.
•Confirm whether the LOC is issued against you by the police / court and also the type of LOC.
•Show the certified copy of the Anticipatory bail to the authorities whilst entering the country. For e.g.: to immigration officers in the airport during the immigration check.
•Authorities should take a photocopy of the Anticipatory bail and hand back the original to you, so that you take your originals with you and proceed.
•Moreover, if the authorities try to detain you, get in touch with concerned Police (Sub Inspector / Deputy Superintendent Police/Investigating Officer) to inform the immigration authorities that you are already enlarged on Anticipatory bail and that they do not require your arrest. If they fail to do so, the victim can file a complaint against them next day detailing the violation of your rights and the contempt of the court order i.e. Anticipatory bail.
•Whilst regularizing the bail or whilst seeking the regular bail in the court, file a supplementary application seeking the LOC to be lifted.
•Failing to file supplementary application, one should look for the bail conditions to make sure there are no restrictions like not to leave the country without prior permission of the court. If there is such condition, please do get the permission from the court and keep the certified copy of the court’s order permitting your departure from the country to produce before the immigration officers in the airport or sea-port.
•One need to push the police to forward the court order to the concerned authorities (the concerned police station and in turn to the immigration authority at the port) to lift the LOC altogether as well as keeping the certified copy with yourself in hand. You need to request the copy of the confirmation for the same from the Police or ask for a letter confirming the same (this is in addition to the court order).

Cancellation or Lifting of LOC:
LOC can be withdrawn by the authority that issued and can also be rescinded by the trial court where case is pending or having jurisdiction over concerned police station on an application by the person concerned.
After getting LOC withdrawn by the authority or court, apply for multiple certified copies of the same. Provide one certified copy with covering letter to investigating officer; SP/DSP concerned and send a copy to the nodal officer at, ‘Deputy Director, Bureau of Immigration (Bol), East Block-VIII, R K Puram, New Delhi-110066.
If you have LOC removal court order, the immigration officer would contact the originator and only on confirmation the LOC will be cancelled or lifted.

Authored by:
Adv. Shirin Yusuf,
Associate,
MENTO ASSOCIATES.

JURISDICTION IN SECTION 498A CASES

JURISDICTION in a lay mans language means ‘The official power to make legal decisions and judgements’. However, in a deeper sense it means ‘The authority given to a court to try cases and rule on legal matters within a particular geographic area over certain types of legal cases’.

SECTION 498(A) OF THE INDIAN PENAL CODE:
Husband or relative of husband of a woman subjecting her to cruelty: Whoever, being the husband or the relative of the husband of a woman, subjects such woman to cruelty shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years and shall also be liable to fine.

“Cruelty” means:
a) any willful conduct which is of such a nature as is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health (whether mental or physical) of the woman; or
b) harassment of the woman where such harassment is with a view to coercing her or any person related to her to meet any unlawful demand for any property or valuable security or is on account of failure by her or any person related to her to meet such demand.

Normally, every criminal offense is inquired into and tried by a court within whose local jurisdiction it is committed. However, as per section 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, an offense can also be tried by a court within whose jurisdiction the consequence of the offense ensues.

Taking the spirit of Section 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, in a landmark judgment in Rupali Devi V State of Uttar Pradesh and Others (AIR 2019 Supreme Court 1790), Supreme Court held that the ‘Complaint alleging cruelty can be filed in the courts where wife takes shelter after leaving or driven away from matrimonial home’
The Hon’ble Supreme Court was of the view that even if the acts of physical cruelty committed in the matrimonial house may have ceased and such acts may not occur at the parental home, there can be no doubt that the mental trauma and psychological distress caused by the acts of the husband including verbal exchanges that compelled the wife to leave the matrimonial home and take shelter with her parents would continue to persist at the parental home. Therefore, the mental cruelty borne out of physical cruelty or abusive and humiliating verbal exchanges would continue in the parental home even though there may not be any overt act of physical cruelty at such place.
It is further opined that, even the silence of the wife may have an underlying element of an emotional distress and mental agony. The wife’s sufferings at the parental home though may be directly attributable to commission of acts of cruelty by the husband at the matrimonial home would, undoubtedly, be the consequences of the acts committed at the matrimonial home. Such consequences, by itself, would amount to distinct offences committed at parental home where she has taken shelter. The adverse effects in the mental health in the parental home though on account of acts committed at the matrimonial home amount to commission of cruelty within the meaning of Section 498-A at the parental home.

The three-judge bench interpreted the legal provision during a reference made in 2012, to decide whether a woman forced to leave her matrimonial home on account of cruelty can initiate and access the legal process within the jurisdiction of the courts where she was forced to take shelter.

In reference, the court held that the case can be lodged by the wife at her parental home even when no overt act of cruelty or harassment is committed by the husband there. The offences of such kind are contemplated under Section 179 CrP.C.

CONCLUSION:
Therefore, the courts at where the wife takes shelter after leaving or driven away from matrimonial home on account of acts of cruelty committed by the husband or his relatives, would, dependent on factual situations, also have jurisdiction to entertain a complaint alleging commission of offences under Section 498-A of Indian Penal Code.

Authored by:
Adv MEGHA MOHAN
Associate
MENTO ASSOCIATES